The seed catalogues are calling your name, but your home leaves much to be desired to start this years seeds. Maybe you don’t have a south facing window, or the one you do have has no ledge to rest plants on, or your apartment is basically a window-less dungeon. You’d like to get a grow light set up, but let’s be real. You don’t have the space, your kids or pets would get into everything, and you just feel like scrapping the whole idea. Besides, who has $200-$600 for a really nice set-up with shelves and everything?
There is another way.
Do you drink milk from plastic jugs? (Or could you get someone who does to save theirs for you?)
Do you have a small deck or other flat outdoor space that gets a decent amount of light?
Great! You can start seeds this year… even if you live in a place as cold as zone 3. I’ll show you how.
Like to see how it’s done? You can watch this video below if you prefer that kind of content:
Seed Starting Without a Grow Light or a Window
The seed starting method I’m sharing with you today sounds too good to be true–but I promise you that it does actually work, although there are a few limitations I’ll share at the end. Winter sowing originally started out as a cheap and effective way to start perennial flowers from seeds, but the method can be applied to vegetables as well.
I live near Saskatoon, SK, which is in zone 3b and has a short growing season of approximately 100 days, give or take depending on that year’s weather and which sources of frost dates you believe. In 2018, I tried my first small experiment with winter sowing (or milk jug gardening, as it’s sometimes referred to), and it was a success.
Winter Sowing Works–Even in Cold Climates Like Zone 3
I started a few cool-weather vegetables that I thought had a decent chance of succeeding–lettuce, kale, Swiss chard, spinach, and radishes. The Swiss chard and radishes failed, but I was very pleased with how the lettuce, kale, and spinach turned out.
UPDATE: I got both the Swiss chard and the radishes to work the second year.
The successful plants were the first to be ready in my garden and didn’t need any additional hardening off. Plus, since they were started outside, they didn’t take up precious window or grow light space in my modest house.
P.S. If you’re in a cold climate like I am, the name “winter sowing” is a bit of a misnomer, especially if you’re trying this with vegetables. I didn’t put my milk jugs out until the end of March, hoping to avoid -30 or -40 weather. In warmer climates, I’d expect you could actually put yours out in winter.
How to Get Started Winter Sowing with Milk Jugs
To start your own flowers or vegetables, you’ll need…
- Empty Milk Jugs
- Potting Soil
- A Fade-Resistant, Permanent Marker
- Duct Tape
- Garden Planner, to keep track of everything
Start by cutting the milk jug into two pieces to create a place for the soil and seeds. Fill the bottom part with potting soil and spread your seeds.
Add a bit of water to the milk jug. You can see approximately how much I add in my Instagram Story highlights.
Next, tape the top part of the milk jug back on and label each jug with what you planted. Write down which jug has what in your garden planner as well. Last year I thought my permanent marker would be good enough, but the sun and moisture washed it out completely by the time the plants were ready.
I’ve actually found much better success with putting a garden marker inside the container itself. The words don’t fade out at all, and you can reuse the markers from year to year.
And that’s it! Set it and forget it until the snow melts, and check on it a week or two before you’re ready to plant.
What Vegetables Work Best for Winter Sowing?
Not every vegetable is a good candidate for winter sowing. Heat-loving vegetables that need to be started early, like tomatoes, peppers, eggplants, or artichokes, would not do well. Avoid vegetables that don’t like to be transplanted, such as carrots, beets, or really, any root vegetable you can think of.
I’ve also experimented with pumpkins and cucumbers, but I put them out in their milk jugs much later–probably late April.
Vegetables don’t actually need freeze-and-thaw cycles to germinate. However, this method does seem to produce much stronger starters for transplanting. As I experiment more, I will let you know what vegetables are successful and when I think the best time to put your containers out is.
Related: The Best Vegetables & Flowers to Start with Winter Sowing
Can Annual Flowers Be Started Using Winter Sowing?
Yes! So far, I’ve started marigolds, zinnias, calendula, and zinnias using the winter sowing methods and hope to keep experimenting with even more flowers.
If you want to experiment with starting annual flowers using milk jugs, it’s a good idea to pick flowers that have a shorter date to maturity, unless you have a longer growing season.
If you’re using the winter sowing method to start perennial flower seeds, like it was intended, feel free to try any perennial that can be started from seed and put them out any time in the winter.
Have you tried winter sowing? (and in what zone?) I’d love to hear about your experience in the comments.
If you liked this blog post, find me on Facebook, TikTok, and Instagram for more cold-climate vegetable gardening tips, delicious recipes, and cut flower goodness! I also make weekly videos over on my YouTube channel. I hope to see you there!
P.S. If you love the content I create for Shifting Roots, consider joining our community on Patreon. Your support means the world to me and I am grateful for each and every one of you!
HAVE YOU TRIED SEED STARTING, ONLY TO BE LEFT WITH STRETCHED-OUT SEEDLINGS AND DEAD PLANTS?
You’re not a bad gardener–you just need a little know-how. For the price of a few seed packets, you can stop wasting time and money, and start growing seedlings that actually live and you get to harvest. Don’t miss out on another growing season. Get your copy of Seed Starting Success now!
Learn the Basics of Gardening in Just a Few Minutes
Gardening doesn't have to be complicated. Learn the basics in minutes, get started with your first garden in a day or less, and start your lifetime gardening adventure.
Enter your name and email address to download the Quick Start Garden Guide. You'll also get a mini-email course and weekly gardening tips and advice.
Join the conversation